Athletic Wall of Fame
| Name | Year | Sport | Year | Sport | Year | Sport |
| Joe Thering | 1953 | Track | ||||
| Don Schafer | 1956 | Football | ||||
| Richard Paisley | 1958 | Track | ||||
| Dave Jacobs | 1959, 1960 | Track | ||||
| Rick Yuncker | 1968 | Football | All-American | |||
| Stanley Pasch | 1971 | Football | ||||
| Mark Schafer | 1972 | Football | ||||
| Mark Clare | 1972 | Football | ||||
| Leo Pasch | 1974 | Football | ||||
| Henry Block | 1975 | Football | ||||
| Rob Brickner | 1975 | Football | ||||
| Steve Gross | 1975 | Football | ||||
| Chris Straus | 1975, 1976 | Football | ||||
| Pete Gross | 1976 | Football | ||||
| Terry Starr | 1978 | Football | ||||
| Doug Theisen | 1978, 1979 | Football | ||||
| Mark Brickner | 1979 | Football | ||||
| George Flaugher | 1980, 1981 | Football | ||||
| Keith Yuncker | 1980, 1981 | Football | ||||
| Brian Mead | 1981 | Football | 1982 | Basketball | ||
| Jim Flaugher | 1982 | Football | ||||
| Tony Wilson | 1982 | Football | ||||
| Tony Straus | 1983 | Football | ||||
| Dennis Lorenz | 1983 | Football | ||||
| Mark Smith | 1983 | Football | ||||
| Kevin Camp | 1984 | Football | ||||
| Jeff Cook | 1985 | Football | ||||
| Randy Schafer | 1985 | Football | 1986 | Baseball | ||
| Duane Schafer | 1985 | Baseball | ||||
| Pete Lorenz | 1987 | Football | ||||
| Paul Streng | 1987 | Football | ||||
| Mike Zeien | 1987 | Football | ||||
| Thad Wilson | 1988 | Football | ||||
| Jeff Bollman | 1988 | Football | ||||
| Todd Schafer | 1988 | Football | 1988 | Baseball | 1988 | Basketball |
| Tom Sharrar | 1989 | Football | ||||
| Jennifer Pasch | 1989 | Track | 1989 | Softball | ||
| Diane Gross | 1990 | Basketball | ||||
| Nick Reihl | 1991 | Football | ||||
| Brian O'Neil | 1991 | Basketball | ||||
| Josh Reihl | 1992 | Football | ||||
| Chris Nelson | 1993 | Track | ||||
| Dave Pung | 1993 | Football | ||||
| Joe Crimando | 1994 | Football | 1994 | Baseball | ||
| Luke Gottleber | 1994 | Football | ||||
| Brad Gross | 1994 | Football | 1994 | Baseball | ||
| Kevin Faber | 1995 | Football | ||||
| Wesley Wilson | 1995 | Football | ||||
| Ryan Nelson | 1995 | Track | ||||
| Kelly Rau | 1996 | Football | ||||
| Kal Cotter | 1997 | Football | ||||
| Craig Onstott | 1997 | Football | ||||
| Abby Pohl | 1999 | Track | ||||
| Nick Maeder | 2000, 2002 | Baseball | 2000 & 01 | Football | ||
| Jonathon Straus | 2000 | Baseball | ||||
| Ben Gross | 2000 | Baseball | ||||
| Erica Bechtel | 2001, 2002 | Track | ||||
| Josh Sanders | 2001 | Baseball | ||||
| Charlie Gross | 2001 | Football | ||||
| Justine Schafer | 2002 | Cross Country | ||||
| Mark Reihl | 2002 | Cross Country | ||||
| Mindy Earl | 2002 | Track | ||||
| Rachael Rau | 2002 | Track | ||||
| Rachael Thielen | 2002 | Track | ||||
| Erik Schumacher | 2002 | Football | ||||
| Ryan Crain | 2003, 2005 | Track | ||||
| Marisa Gross | 2003 | Softball | ||||
| Marisa Gross | 2004 | Volleyball | ||||
| Andrea Straus | 2003 | Softball | ||||
| Beth Vogel | 2003 | Softball | ||||
| Heath Block | 2003, 2004 | Football | ||||
| Brent Peavey | 2003 | Football | ||||
| Chris Scahfer | 2004 | Football | ||||
| Matt Theilen | 2004 | Football | ||||
| Marty Schafer | 2005 | Wrestling | ||||
| Reid Russell | 2005 | Football | ||||
| Brett Bechtel | 2006 | Baseball | ||||
| Kyle Gross | 2006 | Football | ||||
| Sydney Beckwith | 2007 | Basketball | ||||
| Jon Pasch | 2007 | Football | ||||
| Michael Bleise | 2008 | Baseball | ||||
| Jake Ramon | 2008 | Track | ||||
| Justin Sharrar | 2009 | Baseball | ||||
| Kohl Bechtel | 2009 | Baseball | ||||
| Kevin Lucka | 2009 | Track | ||||
| Brian Bleise | 2009 | Basebball | ||||
| Megan Crandall | 2006,2007,2008 , 2009 | Cross Country | ||||
| Kelly David | 2008, 2010 | Track | 2009 | Volleyball | ||
| Brooke Huber | 2010 | Track | ||||
| Jordan Rau | 2009 | Football | ||||
| Kegan Rojas | 2009 | Football | 2010 | Baseball | ||
| Jared Theisen | 2010 | Baseball | ||||
| Morgan Yuncker | 2010 | Softball | ||||
| Maria Daivd | 2010 | Track | ||||
| Nick Pasch | 2010 | Football | ||||
| Brandon Holsworth | 2011 | Baseball | ||||
| Amber Arndt | 2009,2010,2011, 2012 | Track | ||||
| Dew Bechtal | 2011 | Baseball | ||||
| Stone Beckwith | 2011 | Football | 2012 | Basketball | ||
| Monica David | 2012 | Track | ||||
| Maggie Kolb | 2009 | Cross Country | ||||
| Mikayla Jones | 2012 | Track | ||||
| Ryan Marshall | 2012 | Baseball | ||||
| Nate Schafer | 2012 | Football | ||||
| Nick Hoogerhde | 2014 | Baseball | ||||
| Hayden Huber | 2013 | Football | ||||
| Hannah Neyer | 2013 | Cross Country | 2014 | Track | ||
| Anna Reihl | 2014 | Track | ||||
| Ty Rollin | 2013, 2014 | Baseball | 2014 | Football | ||
| Melanie Schafer | 2013 | Track | ||||
| Addie Schumacher | 2012 , 2013 | Track | 2013 | Volleyball | ||
| Ryan Tillmann | 2013 | Football | ||||
| Luke Farrell | 2014 | Football | ||||
| Jacob Flaugher | 2014 | Football | ||||
| Nicole Gross | 2012, 2014 | Track | ||||
| Hayley Neyer | 2014 | Cross Country | ||||
| Nick Pung | 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014 | Cross Country | ||||
| Grace Schafer | 2015 | Track | ||||
| Emily Steffke | 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014 | Cross Country | 2014 & 2015 | Track | ||
| Paige Lorenz | 2016 | Softball | ||||
| Chase Rollin | 2015 | Football | ||||
| Ethan Schafer | 2013, 2014, 2015 | Cross Country | ||||
| Hannah Steffke | 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015 | Cross Country | 2014, 2015, & 2016 | Track | ||
| Kayla Bierschbach | 2015 | Cross Country | 2016 & 2017 | Track | ||
| Natalie Gross | 2016, 2017 | Track | ||||
| David Reihl | 2016 | Cross Country | ||||
| Ashley Reihl | 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018 | Track | ||||
| Madeline Steffke | 2015, 2016 | Cross Country | ||||
| Brett Upton | 2018 | Baseball | ||||
| Keegan Haynes | 2019 | Baseball | ||||
| Gracie Mindel | 2019 | Softball | ||||
| Amy Schwerin | 2017, 2018 | Track | ||||
| Alex Taylor | 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018 | Cross Country | ||||
| Logan Chilman | 2019 | Football | ||||
| Gabby Gamble | 2017 | Track | ||||
| Seth Schafer | 2019 | Football | ||||
| Tray Small | 2019 | Football | ||||
| Chase Smith | 2019 | Football | ||||
| Sidney Upton | 2019 | Softball | ||||
| Matt Kolb | 2020 | Cross Country | ||||
| Angela Kotecki | 2018, 2021 | Track | ||||
| Ethan Locke | 2020 | Football | ||||
| Jesse Pratt |
2018 |
Track | ||||
| Rachal Weber | 2018, 2019, 2020 | Cross Country | ||||
| Cade Block | 2021 | Football | ||||
| Matt Oswald | 2021 | Football | ||||
| Wade Wilson | 2021 | Baseball | 2021 | Football | ||
| Zeta Zeneberg | 2021,2022 | Competitive Cheer | ||||
| Paige Antcliff | 2022 | Softball | ||||
| Kaiden Andrews | 2022 | Baseball | ||||
| Brayden Haynes | 2022 | Baseball | ||||
| Brendan Martin | 2022 | Baseball | ||||
| Hunter Miles | 2022 | Baseball | ||||
| Kaylee Locke | 2019, 2020 | Cross Country | 2022, 2023 | Track | ||
| Tailor Onstott | 2020 | Cross Country | ||||
| Ben Straus | 2022 | Football |